You can count on the fingers of two hands the number of jockeys that have won three or more editions of the Kentucky Derby, and the list is a “who’s who” of great riders. Gary Stevens, Kent Desormeaux, Calvin Borel, Victor Espinoza, Angel Cordero Jr., Isaac Murphy, and Earl Sande have all won three Derbys, and Bill Shoemaker went one better by winning four. But standing together in the annals of Derby history are the two jockeys who have won five editions of the Derby each: Eddie Arcaro and the legendary Bill Hartack.
Born in Pennsylvania in 1932, Hartack was an exercise rider for several years before he started riding in races at Waterford Park—now known as Mountaineer—where he earned his first win in 1952.
Hartack started off slowly, winning just a handful of races that year, but the following year, he emerged in spectacular fashion. Riding one winner almost every day, Hartack dominated racing throughout West Virginia and then stepped up to the big leagues in 1954 and was equally successful.
By riding so many winners, his reputation began to spread, and before long, he was riding not only a high quantity of horses, but high quality horses as well.
Everything came together for Hartack in the mid-1950s. From 1955-1957, he was the leading rider in the nation by races won, visiting the winner’s circle a remarkable 1,105 times while winning 26 percent of his races. Even more significant was the fact that he led all jockeys by money won in 1956 and 1957, when his mounts earned $2,343,955 and $3,060,501. Until Hartack came along, no jockey had ever amassed more than $2 million in purse earnings in a single year. Hartack not only smashed that record, but he eached $3 million as well.
Hartack’s debut in the Derby also came in 1956, and he wasted little time finding success. His first ride came aboard Fabius and they finished second behind Needles before turning the tables on that rival in the Preakness Stakes to give Hartack his first win in a Triple Crown race.
The following year, Hartack won the Kentucky Derby aboard Iron Liege, triumphing by a nose when jockey Bill Shoemaker—riding runner-up Gallant Man—misjudged the finish line and briefly stood up in his saddle.
Three years later in 1960, Hartack won the Derby again, this time aboard Venetian Way, but when that colt disappointed in the Preakness, Hartack jumped ship to ride Celtic Ash in the Belmont. The result? A 5 1/2-length victory over runner-up Venetian Way as Celtic Ash rallied from last, meaning Hartack had won two-thirds of the Triple Crown aboard two different horses.
That year also marked the fourth time in Hartack’s career he led all jockeys by races won, guiding his mounts to 307 victories. But a still greater achievement wasn’t far off. His next two mounts in the Kentucky Derby were Decidedly in 1962 and Northern Dancer in 1964, and Hartack rode both of them to victory. This gave Hartack three winning Derby rides in a row (although not in consecutive years), an achievement that hasn’t been equaled before or since.
Hartack’s ride aboard Northern Dancer in the Kentucky Derby exemplified what made him such a great jockey. Some believed that Northern Dancer didn’t have the stamina to handle the 1 1/4-mile distance of the Derby, and the colt’s regular rider—Bill Shoemaker—gave up the assignment in favor of riding Derby favorite Hill Rise. With Hartack in the saddle, Northern Dancer proved his doubters wrong, saving ground early before shifting outside and getting the jump on Hill Rise turning for home. With powerful strides, Northern Dancer opened up a two-length lead with a furlong to go, then tenaciously held off Hill Rise’s late rally to win by a neck in a then-track-record time of 2:00 flat.
Hartack also guided Northern Dancer to victories in the Preakness Stakes and Queen’s Plate Stakes, as well as a third-place finish in the Belmont Stakes.
Thereafter, Hartack’s incredible streak of Triple Crown success slowed down a bit, but a horse named Majestic Prince helped him re-enter the spotlight. After going unbeaten in seven starts, Majestic Prince was favored to win the 1969 Kentucky Derby, but ended up needing every bit of Hartack’s skill as a jockey to prevail.
Settling in third place as longshot Ocean Roar opened up a big early lead, Hartack allowed the talented colt Arts and Letters to make the first move on the far turn. He then used Majestic Prince’s terrific acceleration to grab the lead in the homestretch and win by a neck.
The Preakness was virtually a repeat of the Derby, with Hartack guiding Majestic Prince to victory over Arts and Letters by a neck, but a Triple Crown sweep was denied when Arts and Letters turned the tables on Majestic Prince in the Belmont Stakes.
Majestic Prince would prove to be Hartack’s last major hurrah as a jockey. He rode in three more editions of the Derby without success, bringing his overall Derby record to an astonishing five wins from 12 starts.
Hartack ended his U.S. riding career with 4,272 wins from 21,535 races. Maintaining the low weight necessary to be a successful jockey in the U.S. had become a challenge, so he shifted his tack to Hong Kong—where horses carry more weight—and rode there for several years until retiring from the sport in 1980.
Horse racing was more than just a business to Hartack, it was a passion. After retiring from the saddle, he remained deeply involved in the sport, working as a racing official and steward at tracks across the country until he passed away in November 2007, just before his 75th birthday.
Perhaps Joe Hirsch said it best when speaking of Hartack in his bookThe First Century: “(Hartack) wanted to win them all. Every one. It was no act; no pose. … He ran each race in his mind with great objectivity, and if he thought he should win and didn’t, he was upset.”
If not for an injury, Bill Hartack might have won a sixth Kentucky Derby. In 1958, he was scheduled to ride Florida Derby winner Tim Tam in the Run for the Roses, but Hartack hurt his leg in a starting-gate accident and was unable to ride the colt, who won the Derby by a half-length.
In addition to his spectacular success in the Triple Crown races, Hartack rode several prominent champions, including Airman’s Guide and Royal Native. Airman’s Guide was a talented filly who won a number of major races across several years, including the Black-Eyed Susan Stakes and Suwannee River Handicap with Hartack in the saddle, while Royal Native was the champion handicap female of 1960 after Hartack guided her to wins in eight stakes races, including the Molly Pitcher Handicap and Arlington Matron Handicap.
Another champion Hartack rode on several occasions was Barbizon, who won the 1956 Garden State Stakes—then the richest race in the world with a purse of $319,000—to become the champion 2-year-old male of the year.
One of the best horses that Hartack ever rode was Gen. Duke. As a 3-year-old in 1957, Gen. Duke defeated the legendary Bold Ruler in the Florida Derby, winning by 1 1/2 lengths in the then-world-record time of 1:46 4/5 for 1 1/8 miles. The colt was favored to win the Kentucky Derby, but surprising defeats in the Blue Grass Stakes and Derby Trial Stakes were followed by the discovery that he had broken a bone in his foot. Gen. Duke never ran again.
Hartack was inducted into the National Museum of Racing and Hall of Fame in 1959.